He won the same award in, and Twila used the chance to make a counter alliance with Scout, Chris, and Eliza, blindsiding Leann. The two started dating, but kept the relationship a secret until after Berry's season aired. Unaware of what happened, the men were thankful to have something dating survivor former probst Jeff eat. Goliah, the two contestants formed a romantic relationship that continues today in San Diego, Calif. Micronesia, where a showmance quickly developed. Probst was ordained dating survivor former probst Jeff a minister in the Universal Life Church during the s. The couple eventually split, and Herzog later appeared on Dr. Contestants are forced to rely on one another to stay in the game, and sometimes that leads to something more—even host Jeff Probst hasn't been immune to the love powers of Survivor.